| Collectively,
physicians in this country will spend about $6 billion for malpractice
insurance this year. Billions more will be spent by hospitals and
nursing homes. That's staggering enough, but the US Department of
Health and Human services estimates defensive medicine is a $25 to
$44 billion dollar cost to the federal government each year. These
figures from the Physician Insurers Association of America begin the
assessment of the problem. The toll doesn't stop here.
It extends to communities that lose their local doctors, and to
patients who bear the stress and risk of traveling long distances
for health care. Sometimes they never reach it, when their condition
prevents completing the trip. For example, a mother in Arizona trying
to drive 40 miles to an obstetrical facility did not reach it, and
a nurse delivered her baby on the side of the road. Her local hospital
had closed its maternity ward.
The Insurance Information Institute reports that medical malpractice
insurers return on net worth was a negative 7.4% in 2002, down from
negative 4.7% in 2001. Three years before it was positive 7.6%.
An early 2004 report shows the value of claims rising 9.7% per year
since 2000, and the number of claims growing 3% a year. Hospital
claims for for 2004 are expected to be $150,000 per claim, and physicians
$178,000 per claim.
How does this work out for individual doctors? While state, region
and specialty make large differences, the Congressional Budget Office
reported in January 2004 that premiums for all physicians nationwide
rose 15% from 200-2002, and for OB/GYN 22%, for internists and general
surgeons 33%. They report average claim payment to be $320,000 in
2002, growing 8% annually. 15 claims were filed per 100 doctors,
with 30% producing insurance payouts.
An article by Kurt Kooyer calls for solutions to a problem for
which liability tort reform in Congress is only the beginning. He
laments "desperate Americans suffering the ill effects of a
diseased tort system that the medical community is powerless to
cure".
|